Trinity College, Cambridge, has purchased O2, the arena formerly known as the Millennium Dome. University class sizes are reportedly increasing, but this seems extreme.
Showing posts with label university. Show all posts
Showing posts with label university. Show all posts
Friday, 9 October 2009
Wednesday, 19 August 2009
Pointless research 3: Zombies would take over and kill everyone - it's official
Philip Munz from Carleton University and the University of Ottawa's Ioan Hudea, Joe Imad and Robert J. Smith? — that question mark isn't a typo, by the way: Smith?'s blog confirms that the question mark is a formal part of his name — have just published a scholarly article called "When Zombies Attack: Mathematical Modelling of an Outbreak of a Zombie Infection", demonstrating that such an outbreak could only be contained by swift and destructive action. Science imitates art.
The writers clearly feel the need to explain that "the scenarios considered are obviously not realistic", but justify their work by continuing: "it is nevertheless instructive to develop mathematical models for an unusual outbreak" (p. 146). Elsewhere, however, the phrasing used rather suggests that they have having difficulty separating real life from the films of George A. Romero, Sam Raimi and Co. The article's final paragraph, for example, eschews the conditional tense in concluding that
a zombie outbreak is likely to lead to the collapse of civilisation, unless it is dealt with quickly. While aggressive quarantine may contain the epidemic, or a cure may lead to coexistence of humans and zombies, the most effective way to contain the rise of the undead is to hit hard and hit often. As seen in the movies, it is imperative that zombies are dealt with quickly, or else we are all in a great deal of trouble.
Joe Imad is quoted as saying: "Modelling zombies would be the same as modelling swine flu, with some differences for sure, but it is much more interesting to read." So it's the same, but different.
There's a worrying implication here that some scientists find their subject boring. Perhaps the writers are hoping for a wider audience than scholarly papers usually achieve. Or perhaps they've got their eye on the Zombie Research Society Awards.
There's a worrying implication here that some scientists find their subject boring. Perhaps the writers are hoping for a wider audience than scholarly papers usually achieve. Or perhaps they've got their eye on the Zombie Research Society Awards.
Wednesday, 12 August 2009
Students might benefit from working first
The Association of School and College Leaders wants A-Level candidates to be able to apply to university after they have received their results. This is an excellent idea; but only if it leads to students working for a year before starting their degree studies. In addition to giving them a taste of the world outside education, this would provide school-leavers with experience of full-time work — helpful in planning study timetables and working to deadlines at university, which requires greater automony than school, and in understanding the kinds of requirements employers have, such as team-working — and an opportunity to earn, save and practise managing their own money, not to mention items to make their CVs look fuller.
Given rising unemployment levels, however, it's unlikely to happen. After all, hasn't the number of university places been increased to keep students off the unemployment lists?
Given rising unemployment levels, however, it's unlikely to happen. After all, hasn't the number of university places been increased to keep students off the unemployment lists?
Social mobility: what is the problem?
Peter Mandelson's increasingly hostile accusations that candidates from poor backgrounds are being deliberately rejected by "elite" universities are now proved beyond doubt to be based on bias, as a new report demonstrates that potential applicants are being influenced by their schools and teachers not to try for top universities, which are perceived to be out of their league. This research has been conducted by the Sutton Trust, a body whose mission coincides with Mandelson's in aiming to '"improve educational opportunities for young people from non-priviledged backgrounds and increase social mobility".
While the perennially biassed are rethinking their stance (always supposing, of course, that they are prepared to accept the evidence), they would be wise to consider the word "elite", which they so often employ pejoratively. The Oxford English Dictionary supplies a succinct definition: "The choice part or flower (of society, or of any body or class of persons)". This certainly supports the idea of a chosen few; yet the same term or concept applied elsewhere, for example in sport, contains no sense of denigration at all, either overt or implicit. Earlier this year, for instance, when Sheffield University's Media Centre headlined a news release "Universities' sporting elite showcase their star potential", these sports specialists were clearly viewed as a good thing. The term was used equally positively in a House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts report for 2005-6 entitled "UK Sport: Supporting elite athletes", while in April 2006 an item reporting on increased financial support for UK sportspeople in preparation for the 2012 Olympics proudly announced "£65m funding boost for elite sport".
The application of the term "elite" in sporting contexts explicitly refers to the best; after all, the best are the ones who win sporting events. Those who are not good at sport must learn early on that life is indeed not a level playing field; but many, perhaps most, may find something else at which they excel where their sporting peers do not and cannot.
So, if elitism is embraced and valorised in sport, why is the word "elite" purely negative when applied to academia? Just like sporting selection panels, universities want to select the best applicants, regardless of background. Just as in sport, league tables are paramount and "excellence" in global competition a requirement for winning and maintaining funding; isn't it incumbent upon universities to attract and accept the best candidates then, just as it is for football clubs to identify and select the best tyro players to train for the future? The British Olympic Association was allowed to rewrite its ski-jumping rules to exclude competitors not in the world top 50, in order to avoid successors to Eddie the Eagle. So an elite is in fact a good thing; after all, who wants delicate brain surgery or a complex heart operation to be performed by someone who was accepted for medical training to fulfil a social quota, not because of aptitude and ability?
Now there is unambiguous evidence to the contrary, it's time to ask why Mandelson and Co have so doggedly insisted that their plans for social mobility have been thwarted by "elite" universities? It's an insistence all the more surprising given that many academics lean politically left, as demonstrated by the policies of their union, the UCU, and the stance of their newspaper of choice, the Guardian.
The answer can only be is that it's easier (and cheaper) to demonise universities than to turn around the schools that are failing to supply "the disadvantaged" with the education they need to deal with everyday life, never mind a degree. The schools' failures are, of course, the politicians' own.
While the perennially biassed are rethinking their stance (always supposing, of course, that they are prepared to accept the evidence), they would be wise to consider the word "elite", which they so often employ pejoratively. The Oxford English Dictionary supplies a succinct definition: "The choice part or flower (of society, or of any body or class of persons)". This certainly supports the idea of a chosen few; yet the same term or concept applied elsewhere, for example in sport, contains no sense of denigration at all, either overt or implicit. Earlier this year, for instance, when Sheffield University's Media Centre headlined a news release "Universities' sporting elite showcase their star potential", these sports specialists were clearly viewed as a good thing. The term was used equally positively in a House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts report for 2005-6 entitled "UK Sport: Supporting elite athletes", while in April 2006 an item reporting on increased financial support for UK sportspeople in preparation for the 2012 Olympics proudly announced "£65m funding boost for elite sport".
The application of the term "elite" in sporting contexts explicitly refers to the best; after all, the best are the ones who win sporting events. Those who are not good at sport must learn early on that life is indeed not a level playing field; but many, perhaps most, may find something else at which they excel where their sporting peers do not and cannot.
So, if elitism is embraced and valorised in sport, why is the word "elite" purely negative when applied to academia? Just like sporting selection panels, universities want to select the best applicants, regardless of background. Just as in sport, league tables are paramount and "excellence" in global competition a requirement for winning and maintaining funding; isn't it incumbent upon universities to attract and accept the best candidates then, just as it is for football clubs to identify and select the best tyro players to train for the future? The British Olympic Association was allowed to rewrite its ski-jumping rules to exclude competitors not in the world top 50, in order to avoid successors to Eddie the Eagle. So an elite is in fact a good thing; after all, who wants delicate brain surgery or a complex heart operation to be performed by someone who was accepted for medical training to fulfil a social quota, not because of aptitude and ability?
Now there is unambiguous evidence to the contrary, it's time to ask why Mandelson and Co have so doggedly insisted that their plans for social mobility have been thwarted by "elite" universities? It's an insistence all the more surprising given that many academics lean politically left, as demonstrated by the policies of their union, the UCU, and the stance of their newspaper of choice, the Guardian.
The answer can only be is that it's easier (and cheaper) to demonise universities than to turn around the schools that are failing to supply "the disadvantaged" with the education they need to deal with everyday life, never mind a degree. The schools' failures are, of course, the politicians' own.
Wednesday, 5 August 2009
The Naming of Parts
The latest report on the state of primary school education in England, based on Key Stage 2 assessments, states that 40% of primary school pupils are failing to achieve the required level (level 4 or above) in English.
The opposition parties, not surprisingly, are blaming Labour. However, in the Conservatives' case ast least, this is somewhat disingenuous. Ripple fade back to Bristol, 1997, where my friend, S, was working as a supply primary teaching since graduating from a four-year teaching training degree at a post-1992 university.
One afternoon, S rang me in a panic. She had been assigned to a "posh" school where she was expected to teach adjectives and adverbs, and she had no idea what these were, never mind how to teach them. Could I help? Well, yes: I could and I did, rather wondering what her alma mater had been teaching her for four years.
Years later, I am still wondering what is being taught in schools. Students studying literature often arrive at university without an understanding of the basic terminology and use of language. Adjectives and adverbs are employed indiscriminately, and past participles incorrectly (sat for seated is almost ubiquitous); the nomenclature of verb tenses is unknown; students seem unaware that the expression of the English present tense can be simple or continuous, and find it hard to grasp the nuances in meaning between the two; sentences are filled with subclauses and continue for half a page with little punctuation and sometimes no active verb. (Many, however, have been taught more sophisticated expressions; lexis and register are recent buzzwords.) Consulting a dictionary is an alien concept.
Schoolteachers have long complained that grammar is "boring" for students (do they really mean for themselves?) and promoted a more flexible approach to teaching based on "encouraging creativity". Yet the naming of parts is a basic principle in every activity. Children are accustomed to learning specialized terms in a range of hobbies and interests: music has its notes, rhythms and scales, ballet its steps and movements, football its moves and rules. Withholding the specialized terms of language does not encourage creativity, but conflicts with the way all specialist pursuits, creative, sporting or academic, must be learnt.
The government has recently promised a further expansion of higher education, with a focus on science, engineering, mathematics and technology; but undergraduates in these disciplines need effective communication skills to understand their subjects and articulate their knowledge. Language is fundamental to all learning and is the key to self-expression in all degree courses, not just those in languages, linguistics or literature: mathematicians, scientists and information technologists also need an understanding of oral and written language in order to communicate adequately in their academic subjects and in their future jobs.
With more people than ever going on to study degrees, schools need to teach sound English expression and that, just like football and music, includes the naming of parts.
The opposition parties, not surprisingly, are blaming Labour. However, in the Conservatives' case ast least, this is somewhat disingenuous. Ripple fade back to Bristol, 1997, where my friend, S, was working as a supply primary teaching since graduating from a four-year teaching training degree at a post-1992 university.
One afternoon, S rang me in a panic. She had been assigned to a "posh" school where she was expected to teach adjectives and adverbs, and she had no idea what these were, never mind how to teach them. Could I help? Well, yes: I could and I did, rather wondering what her alma mater had been teaching her for four years.
Years later, I am still wondering what is being taught in schools. Students studying literature often arrive at university without an understanding of the basic terminology and use of language. Adjectives and adverbs are employed indiscriminately, and past participles incorrectly (sat for seated is almost ubiquitous); the nomenclature of verb tenses is unknown; students seem unaware that the expression of the English present tense can be simple or continuous, and find it hard to grasp the nuances in meaning between the two; sentences are filled with subclauses and continue for half a page with little punctuation and sometimes no active verb. (Many, however, have been taught more sophisticated expressions; lexis and register are recent buzzwords.) Consulting a dictionary is an alien concept.
Schoolteachers have long complained that grammar is "boring" for students (do they really mean for themselves?) and promoted a more flexible approach to teaching based on "encouraging creativity". Yet the naming of parts is a basic principle in every activity. Children are accustomed to learning specialized terms in a range of hobbies and interests: music has its notes, rhythms and scales, ballet its steps and movements, football its moves and rules. Withholding the specialized terms of language does not encourage creativity, but conflicts with the way all specialist pursuits, creative, sporting or academic, must be learnt.
The government has recently promised a further expansion of higher education, with a focus on science, engineering, mathematics and technology; but undergraduates in these disciplines need effective communication skills to understand their subjects and articulate their knowledge. Language is fundamental to all learning and is the key to self-expression in all degree courses, not just those in languages, linguistics or literature: mathematicians, scientists and information technologists also need an understanding of oral and written language in order to communicate adequately in their academic subjects and in their future jobs.
With more people than ever going on to study degrees, schools need to teach sound English expression and that, just like football and music, includes the naming of parts.
Wednesday, 29 July 2009
Pandora's Box (1)
The Guardian's comment page today considers the future of British universities, complaining that "Every expansion since the redbricks were built has been branded an expansion too far by an elite convinced that only they are [sic] fit to benefit from university. If they [sic] had prevailed,* many of today's lawyers and accountants would instead be consigned to dead-end jobs".
That seems to express precisely why the universities should have been left alone.
* The internet version substitutes "had had their way" for "prevailed".
That seems to express precisely why the universities should have been left alone.
* The internet version substitutes "had had their way" for "prevailed".
Going up, but there's no way back
Labour's obsession with what it sees as the universities' "failure" (never its own) to accommodate the working classes ignores the fact that an academy education is but one factor involved in social mobility.
As Jenni Russell observes, "Anyone who hopes to be socially mobile has, by definition, to learn to read a culture that is not the one they [sic] grew up with". This means learning to identify and adopt the behaviour of a different class in order to fit into both professional and social situations. (Of course, it also means joining Labour's "enemy", the middle classes, and thus accepting its contempt and hatred, a point apparently beyond the understanding of Millburn, Mandelson & Co. As Shakespeare put it, "this was sometime a paradox, but now the time gives it proof").
As always, Labour seems concerned to present social mobility as something that can only benefit the socially mobile; Tony Harrison's biographical poem "Bookends" suggests otherwise, clearly warning that headlong mobility can cause rifts nothing can heal:
Blood, they say, is thicker than water; it may be that fear of disloyalty and family breaches need addressing if Labour is serious about tackling the reasons for faltering social mobility.
As Jenni Russell observes, "Anyone who hopes to be socially mobile has, by definition, to learn to read a culture that is not the one they [sic] grew up with". This means learning to identify and adopt the behaviour of a different class in order to fit into both professional and social situations. (Of course, it also means joining Labour's "enemy", the middle classes, and thus accepting its contempt and hatred, a point apparently beyond the understanding of Millburn, Mandelson & Co. As Shakespeare put it, "this was sometime a paradox, but now the time gives it proof").
As always, Labour seems concerned to present social mobility as something that can only benefit the socially mobile; Tony Harrison's biographical poem "Bookends" suggests otherwise, clearly warning that headlong mobility can cause rifts nothing can heal:
I
Baked the day she suddenly dropped deadwe chew it slowly that last apple pie.
Shocked into sleeplessness you're scared of bed.
We never could talk much, and now don't try.
You're like book ends, the pair of you, she'd say,
Hog that grate, say nothing, sit, sleep, stare…
The "scholar" me, you, worn out on poor pay,
only our silence made us seem a pair.
Not as good for staring in, blue gas,
too regular each bud, each yellow spike.
At night you need my company to pass
and she not here to tell us we're alike!
Your life's all shattered into smithereens.
Back in our silences and sullen looks,
for all the Scotch we drink, what's still between 's
not the thirty or so years, but books, books, books.
II
The stone's too full. The wording must be terse.
There's scarcely room to carve the FLORENCE on it--
Come on, it's not as if we're wanting verse.
It's not as if we're wanting a whole sonnet!
After tumblers of neat Johnny Walker
(I think that both of us we're on our third)
you said you'd always been a clumsy talker
and couldn't find another, shorter word
for 'beloved' or for 'wife' in the inscription,
but not too clumsy that you can't still cut:
You're supposed to be the bright boy at description
and you can't tell them what the fuck to put!
I've got to find the right words on my own.
I've got the envelope that he'd been scrawling,
mis-spelt, mawkish, stylistically appalling
but I can't squeeze more love into their stone.
Blood, they say, is thicker than water; it may be that fear of disloyalty and family breaches need addressing if Labour is serious about tackling the reasons for faltering social mobility.
Thursday, 23 July 2009
More university places (follow-up)
With £100 million due to be cut from the education budget, reports of the existence of a secret list featuring up to 30 universities thought to be in danger of financial failure in the next year, and news that 50% of graduates are earning below the repayment threshold, how exactly is the government planning to fund the 10,000 extra university places announced only a week ago?
And with grants frozen and fees rising, who will be able to take advantage of the additional places?
And with grants frozen and fees rising, who will be able to take advantage of the additional places?
Friday, 17 July 2009
More university places
Earlier this month, the Association of Graduate Recruiters reported that the number of graduate positions had decreased by 25%, with 48 graduates competing for each post and starting salaries frozen.
Now Gordon Brown promises to provide up to 10,000 extra university places to accommodate increasing demand fuelled by recession and rising unemployment. Perhaps the recession will be a distant memory by the time the additional students graduate and there will be degree-level posts for all. Or perhaps this idea is as short-term as the contracts of the academics likely to be employed to teach them, and simply a way to keep more people off the unemployment lists.
Now Gordon Brown promises to provide up to 10,000 extra university places to accommodate increasing demand fuelled by recession and rising unemployment. Perhaps the recession will be a distant memory by the time the additional students graduate and there will be degree-level posts for all. Or perhaps this idea is as short-term as the contracts of the academics likely to be employed to teach them, and simply a way to keep more people off the unemployment lists.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)